- Neudorf Pinot Rose 2011, "Cherry and spice and all things nice. Robust, flavoursome rose in an off/ dry style. Just the thing for supping on a summer picnic." Top NZ 2011 rose.
- Bob Campbell MW
- Neudorf Pinot Rose 2011. " Vivacious pink/pale red summer sipper with fresh strawberry, apricot and spice flavours, dryish, finely poised and rich. 5 stars" Top 2011 NZ Rose
- Michael Cooper, NZ Listener Dec 2011
- Neudorf Pinot Rose 2011 "This is the best rose I've tasted from the current vintage. It's off-dry, with lots of strawberry and spice. Rose is best drunk young, so if you can get any from 2011, go for it"
- Michael Cooper
- Neudorf Pinot Rosé 2011 "Dryish strawberries notes on this rosé the aftertaste is succulent,soothing and sensational."
- John Hawkesby, Radio NZ
- Neudorf Pinot Rose 2011 "Quite a robust, flavorsome Rose with a modest amount of sweetness restrained by light acidity and gentle tannins to give a nearly dry finish. Charming wine with cherry and hints of spice.91/100 Four and a half stars"
- Bob Campbell MW
- Neudorf Rose 2010 “Neudorf earns my vote for making wines of a higher standard across the board that any other New Zealand winery. Best known for its chardonnay and pinot noir, this stylish Nelson winery has applied the same fastidious methods to making a very smart rose. Attractively scented wine with strawberry, pot pourri and wild herb flavours. Initial sweetness is balanced by fine tannins and gentle acidity to give a drying (through not bone dry) finish. Charming wine in a distinctive and individual style.”
- Bob Campbell MW
- “Intense, fresh aromatic elderflower and herb with refreshingly full flavours of passion fruit and a cleansing dry finish; not Marlborough, and all the better for its difference in character. Try with goat's cheese.”
- Anthony Rose, The Wine Gang UK 2010
- Neudorf Pinot Rosé 2008, “Very pale pink. Pure, delicate with surprising power and length. The texture is ethereal and the finish dry. Very attractive Rose - totally charming. ”
- Bob Campbell MW
- Neudorf Pinot Rosé 2008 - "For proof that top quality Rosé is being made in New Zealand, look no further than Neudorf. Love the fresh berry flavours balanced by the firm acids. Very food friendly and definitely one of my top five Kiwi Rosés."
- Joelle Thompson, New Zealand Herald
- Neudorf Pinot Rose 2006- "Wow, Strawberries and cream, fascinating texture and flavour. This has to be my personal favourite, but then I've never had a Neudorf wine that I didn't like. I enjoyed it as an aperitif. My friends hardly get a look in."
- Rachel Stansfield, Foodlovers
